Advanced Composition

1

What is a Discourse Community?

1. What is a Discourse Community?

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

The excerpt provided is a table of contents and course introduction that frames the study of discourse communities as the first unit in a composition course focused on rhetorical situation, audience, purpose, context, and genre.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • Course structure: Four units covering discourse communities, multimodality, narrative writing, and argumentation.
  • Central framework: Understanding the rhetorical situation—the interplay between audience, purpose, context, and genre.
  • Unit 1 focus: Identifying and understanding discourse communities as a foundation for effective writing.
  • Practical goal: Equipping students to tailor writing to various audiences (academic, professional, personal) and adapt messages to different rhetorical contexts.

📚 Course framework and goals

📚 What the course covers

The excerpt describes a semester-long composition course organized into four major units:

UnitTopicFocus
Unit 1Discourse CommunitiesWhat is a discourse community, discourse vs. discourse community, identifying your community
Unit 2MultimodalityWriting for the web, design principles, accessibility and inclusion
Unit 3NarrationPurpose of narration, narrative writing, podcast scripting
Unit 4ArgumentationWhat is argumentation, rhetoric, structure, researched arguments, evidence failures
  • Each unit is designed to equip students with information needed to complete four major assignments.
  • The course also includes self-reflection components and an appendix with foundational writing skills.

🎯 Core learning objectives

The course aims to provide "invaluable tools and strategies to navigate the complexities of the rhetorical situation."

Rhetorical situation: The interplay between audience, purpose, context, and genre that shapes effective written communication.

  • Students learn to craft writing that considers these four elements together, not in isolation.
  • The goal is to develop "clarity, relevance, and impact" by understanding how these factors interact.

🎭 The rhetorical situation elements

👥 Audience awareness

  • What it means: Tailoring writing to various audiences—academic, professional, or personal.
  • Why it matters: By considering "the unique needs, expectations, and perspectives of your audience," writers can communicate more effectively.
  • How to apply: Learn to adapt your message based on who will read it.
  • Example: Writing for a professional audience requires different language and structure than writing for a personal blog.

🎯 Purpose clarification

  • What it means: Identifying and articulating your objectives as a writer.
  • The excerpt lists common purposes: "to inform, persuade, entertain, or provoke."
  • Why precision matters: "Articulating your objectives with precision is essential for crafting focused and purposeful writing."
  • Outcome: Developing "a stronger sense of authorial voice and agency in your writing endeavors."
  • Don't confuse: Purpose is not just "what you're writing about" but "what you want to accomplish" with your writing.

🌍 Context consideration

Context: Cultural, historical, social, and institutional factors that influence the reception and interpretation of written texts.

  • What it involves: Situating your writing within its broader context.
  • Why it matters: Understanding context helps craft "messages that resonate with your audience and resonate with contemporary discourse."
  • The excerpt emphasizes that context shapes how texts are received and interpreted, not just how they are written.

📝 Genre understanding

  • What the course explores: "The nuances of genre, examining how different forms and styles of writing serve distinct purposes and audiences."
  • Genre is presented as one of the four pillars of the rhetorical situation.
  • Key insight: Different genres serve different purposes and audiences—understanding this helps writers choose appropriate forms.
  • The excerpt does not provide specific genre definitions but indicates they will be explored throughout the course.

🗂️ Unit 1 preview: Discourse communities

🗂️ What Unit 1 covers

The first unit focuses on discourse communities through three chapters:

  1. Chapter 1: What is a Discourse Community?
  2. Chapter 2: Discourse and Discourse Community
  3. Chapter 3: Identifying your Discourse Community
  • This unit serves as the foundation for the course, suggesting that understanding discourse communities is essential before exploring other writing contexts.
  • The excerpt does not define "discourse community" but positions it as the starting point for understanding effective composition.

🔗 Connection to the larger course

  • Unit 1 is the first of four units, each aligned with a major assignment.
  • The course moves from understanding communities (Unit 1) to multimodal composition (Unit 2) to storytelling (Unit 3) to argumentation (Unit 4).
  • This progression suggests that knowing your discourse community informs how you compose in different modes and genres.

📖 Note on excerpt content

Important: The provided excerpt consists primarily of a table of contents and a general course introduction. It does not contain substantive content explaining what a discourse community is, how to identify one, or specific characteristics that define discourse communities. The actual instructional content on discourse communities would appear in Chapters 1–3 of Unit 1, which are not included in this excerpt.

2

Discourse and Discourse Community

2. Discourse and Discourse Community

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

The excerpt provided is a table of contents and introductory material that outlines a course structure but does not contain substantive content about discourse or discourse communities.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • The excerpt consists primarily of a table of contents listing chapters, including "Chapter 2 – Discourse and Discourse Community."
  • The introduction describes a four-unit course structure focused on writing, rhetoric, and community analysis.
  • No definitions, explanations, or theoretical content about discourse or discourse communities appear in the excerpt.
  • The material references discourse communities as a topic to be covered but does not explain what they are or how they function.

📋 Content limitations

📋 What the excerpt contains

The provided text includes:

  • A table of contents listing course chapters and units
  • An introduction to an Advanced Composition course
  • Descriptions of four course units and their assignments
  • General statements about writing process and rhetorical situation

❌ What is missing

The excerpt does not contain the actual content of "Chapter 2 – Discourse and Discourse Community."

  • No definition of "discourse" appears in the text
  • No definition of "discourse community" is provided
  • No theoretical frameworks, examples, or explanations of these concepts are present
  • The chapter title is listed in the table of contents, but the chapter content itself is not included

🔍 Course context only

🎯 Unit 1 mentions

The introduction states that Unit 1 will help students:

  • Explore understanding of community and communication
  • Learn what is meant by "discourse"
  • Become comfortable discussing "discourse communities"
  • Identify their own discourse communities

However, the excerpt does not provide the actual instructional content that would teach these concepts.

📝 Assignment structure

The course includes four units with different focuses, but the excerpt only describes assignment types (community profile, storytelling, argumentation) without explaining the theoretical concepts of discourse and discourse community that the chapter title promises.

3

Identifying your Discourse Community

3. Identifying your Discourse Community

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

Identifying your own discourse communities through self-assessment helps you understand which groups you belong to and prepares you to engage meaningfully with their shared communication practices and research.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • What you need to identify: your interests, academic major, employment, social groups, or organizational memberships all point to your discourse communities.
  • Why identification matters: knowing your discourse community helps you create content that fits your audience's context and use the specialized language (lexis) common to that community.
  • How it supports research: this self-assessment focuses your thinking on what a discourse community is and helps identify potential organizations for research projects.
  • Common confusion: you may belong to multiple discourse communities at once—you don't have to pick just one; different aspects of your life connect you to different communities.
  • Practical application: this knowledge will be useful throughout composition and research work, especially when selecting organizations or topics to study.

🔍 The self-assessment process

🔍 What the assessment asks

The excerpt presents a self-assessment designed to help you identify your discourse community or communities through targeted questions.

  • The questions focus on concrete aspects of your life: major, employment, memberships, interests.
  • You may not have declared a major yet—that's fine; the assessment works for students at different stages.
  • Example: a business major would use this to identify business-related discourse communities, but any student can apply the same process to their own situation.

🎯 Purpose of the exercise

The self-assessment serves multiple goals:

  • Immediate goal: help you recognize which discourse communities you are part of.
  • Course goal: prepare you for composition and research work in your discipline.
  • Research goal: identify potential organizations you may use in research projects.
  • Conceptual goal: deepen your understanding of what a discourse community is by applying it to your own life.

🗂️ What identification enables

🗂️ Creating in context

Knowing your discourse community will help you to create within a context that is common to your audience.

  • "Creating in context" means producing work that fits the expectations and norms of your community.
  • You're not writing in a vacuum—you're writing for people who share certain assumptions and practices.
  • The context includes the problems the community cares about, the genres they use, and the values they hold.

🗣️ Using shared language (lexis)

Knowing your discourse community will also help you to craft a compelling treatise that uses lexis (lingo, language) that is common to your discourse community.

  • Lexis = the specialized vocabulary, jargon, or "lingo" that a discourse community uses.
  • Every discourse community has its own lexis—words and phrases that insiders understand but outsiders might not.
  • Using the right lexis makes your writing more credible and shows you understand the community.
  • Don't confuse: lexis isn't just fancy words; it's the specific language that community members use to communicate efficiently with each other.

📚 Identifying written genres

The self-assessment also helps you recognize the written genres your discourse communities use.

  • Different communities produce different types of documents: reports, proposals, articles, social media posts, etc.
  • Knowing these genres helps you understand how communication happens in that community.
  • Example: a professional organization might use formal reports and white papers, while a hobbyist community might use blog posts and forum threads.

🧩 Key aspects to assess

🧩 Multiple dimensions of identity

The excerpt lists several dimensions to consider when identifying your discourse communities:

DimensionWhat it meansWhy it matters
InterestsWhat you care about or enjoyOften connects you to focal communities (shared interest groups)
Academic majorYour field of studyConnects you to disciplinary discourse communities
EmploymentWhere you workConnects you to professional and workplace communities
Social groupYour friend circles, clubsConnects you to local communities with shared practices
Organizational membershipsAssociations, clubs, teamsConnects you to both local and focal communities

🔄 Ongoing relevance

The excerpt emphasizes that this identification process isn't just a one-time exercise:

  • It will be helpful "as you move through Composition and Research in the business discipline" (or your own discipline).
  • The knowledge builds over time and supports future research and writing tasks.
  • Understanding your discourse communities is foundational for the rest of the course and beyond.
4

Multimodality

4. Multimodality

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

Multimodality—the strategic combination of linguistic, visual, gestural, spatial, and aural modes—is crucial for effective digital communication because it enhances meaning, engages audiences, and helps convey information more clearly than text alone.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • What multimodality means: using more than one "mode" or method to communicate meaning (words, images, sounds, gestures, spatial arrangement).
  • Why it matters: digital communication requires thoughtful design that combines elements to capture attention, build trust, and elicit responses aligned with communication goals.
  • The five modes: linguistic (words), visual (images, color, formatting), gestural (body language, facial expressions), spatial (arrangement), and aural (sound).
  • Common confusion: knowing how to use a tool (practical skill) vs. knowing why or to what effect (rhetorical skill)—just because you can do something doesn't mean you should.
  • Rhetorical nature: effective multimodality requires considering audience, purpose, and context to avoid overwhelming readers or failing to engage them.

📜 Historical context and evolution

📜 Early internet limitations

  • In the early days of the internet, communication was almost entirely text-based.
  • No online videos or pictures; text wasn't even formatted with variety in fonts, colors, sizes, or spacing.
  • Users faced walls of text that were difficult to navigate—by today's standards, a terrible website design.

🚀 Rapid evolution of digital capabilities

  • The internet evolved to allow thoughtfully designed web pages combining visual and auditory elements.
  • Modern digital communication includes video editing, animation tools, live streaming, and web applications.
  • These tools allow incorporation of various media without requiring HTML expertise.
  • Digital communication has become increasingly complex and multimodal.

📚 Shift in composition instruction

  • Composition courses are expanding beyond text-based writing to include multimodal writing strategies.
  • This integration of visual and aural elements develops literacy skills across multiple platforms.
  • Allows writers to think more deeply and creatively about conveying information to intended audiences.

🎯 Core concept: What is multimodality?

🎯 Definition and basic principle

Multimodality: literally means more than one "mode" or method to communicate meaning.

  • A message often has words (one mode), but also includes font choice, size, color, formatting effects like bold or italic.
  • These additional elements are also methods of communicating and significantly affect how someone reads and interprets meaning.
  • Important to consider communication goals and how different modes—beyond word choice—influence effectiveness.

🧩 The five modes

The excerpt identifies five distinct modes that make up multimodality:

ModePrimary Function
LinguisticWritten and spoken words
VisualThings people see (images, colors, formatting)
GesturalBody movements and facial expressions
SpatialArrangement of elements
AuralSound elements

⚠️ Don't confuse: Practical vs. rhetorical skill

  • Practical literacy (knowing how): surface-level skill—knowing how to make text bold, create a bar graph, paste an image, embed a video.
  • Rhetorical literacy (knowing why or to what effect): deeper understanding of when and why to use specific tools.
  • Example: Most people know how to make text bold, but understanding when bold text enhances vs. overwhelms a message requires rhetorical thinking.
  • The excerpt emphasizes: "just because you can do something doesn't mean that you should."

🔤 Linguistic mode: Words and structure

🔤 Overview of linguistic elements

Written and spoken words are the primary tools to express meaning in daily communication (conversation, text messages, emails, letters, blog posts).

Within this category, several elements can clarify meaning or create confusion:

📝 Word choice

  • Different words carry different connotations.
  • Example: "stubborn" (negative—hard-headed, difficult) vs. "tenacious" (positive—determined, self-confident) describe the same quality differently.
  • Vague words create confusion; precise wording improves clarity.
    • Example: "vegetables" on a shopping list is vague; "baby carrots" is precise.
  • Vocabulary should match audience understanding—avoid jargon they won't understand or vocabulary that's too simplistic.
  • Word choice significantly affects how others interpret meaning and the speaker's credibility (ethos).

✏️ Grammar

  • Grammar dictates how words are structured within sentences to create complete thoughts.
  • Following grammatical rules allows others to process information more easily, focusing on content instead of structure.
  • Some rules are more important than others:
    • Subject-verb agreement and complete sentences help understanding.
    • Rules like "don't end sentences with prepositions" are less critical, especially in informal contexts.
  • Context matters: effective grammar depends on audience, occasion, and communication method.
    • Verbal communication: naturally includes starts, stops, incomplete sentences.
    • Formal written communication (emails, articles): tends to follow grammar rules.
    • Informal messaging (texts, social media): intentionally breaks rules to engage readers or communicate tone.
  • Punctuation can be broken intentionally to enhance meaning.
  • Important note: Despite expanded digital writing (hashtags, emojis, "texty" language), correct grammar still matters.

🏗️ Sentence structure

  • Different sentence types are grammatically correct but come across differently to audiences.
  • Many short, simple sentences: seem choppy and disjointed.
  • Long, complex sentences (especially several together): difficult to follow.
  • Context determines "right" structure:
    • Younger audiences or complex/unfamiliar topics: shorter sentences or bulleted lists for easier understanding.
    • Formal papers or casual general topics: variety of simple and complex sentences creates fluidity.

🗂️ Organization of sentences and paragraphs

  • For longer messages (essays, articles, speeches), organization requires careful consideration so ideas build logically.
  • Academic essays use thesis statements and topic sentences to create cohesion and help readers follow.
    • Thesis gives the main point; topic sentences relate directly to that main idea.
  • Blog articles may not have formal thesis but still have introduction with main idea (often called a "nut graph").
  • Paragraphs grouped under headings expand on the main idea.
  • Even short/informal communication needs organization.
    • Example: An email wouldn't start with bullet points—readers would be confused. It needs a short introduction clarifying subject and contextualizing the bulleted list.

🔗 Linguistic mode in context

  • While linguistic mode is often the most important tool for communicating meaning, it doesn't stand alone.
  • Other modes enhance meaning alongside linguistics.
  • Sometimes linguistic mode isn't the most important:
    • Example: Climactic movie scene—watching it yourself vs. having someone describe it. Visual experience creates fuller understanding and emotional connection.
    • Example: Hour-long lecture in monotone voice vs. varied tone/inflection with pauses, gestures, facial expressions, and visual aids. Multimodal approach is more engaging and easier to understand.

👁️ Visual mode: Seeing meaning

👁️ Overview of visual elements

The visual mode includes things people see that help them interpret message meaning—from simple visual cues to complex images and videos.

Visual cues greatly enhance messages to make them more engaging and readable.

🔤 Font choices

  • Font is a visual element that coincides with linguistic mode.
  • Basic fonts (Arial, Times New Roman) suggest academic or serious messages.
  • Each font carries a "personality" that may or may not be appropriate:
    • Script font like Edwardian: formal, sophisticated—appropriate for wedding invitations, not academic essays or kids' birthday parties.
    • Playful font like Curlz: suited for birthday parties, inappropriate for funeral bulletins or political ads.
  • Font strategies for emphasis: larger font, bold, italics, underlined words demonstrate importance when used appropriately.
  • Larger bold font for headings helps readers follow structure and find main ideas.

📐 Formatting

  • Subtle visual cues that affect readability.
  • Breaking large text blocks into separate paragraphs (with spaces between or tabs at beginning) makes text more readable and easier to follow.
  • Formatting includes: line spacing (leading), alignment, horizontal spacing between letters (kerning), line breaks, inset text, hanging indents.
  • These seem obvious but are crucial—when ignored, messages become harder to read.
    • Example: Right-aligned article is harder to read and frustrates readers.
  • Intentional choices that go against conventions can grab attention and complement messages.
    • Example: Right-aligned ad text might balance page elements or create tension with audience.

🎨 Color

  • Colors catch attention and enhance aesthetic appeal.
  • Symbolic uses: evoke certain emotions or moods.
    • Black and white or sepia: nostalgia or timelessness.
    • Bright, vibrant colors: energy and positivity.
  • Strategic use draws attention to particular text or image parts.
    • Example: Schindler's List is black and white except for one girl's red coat, forcing audiences to notice that object and consider significance.
  • In text documents, color draws attention to headings or titles.
  • Blue, underlined text signals hyperlinks readers can click.
  • Organizations use color palettes for branding—selecting colors that correspond with logos and integrating them into websites and marketing materials.

📷 Images

  • Pictures and graphics significantly enhance messages.
  • Help audiences understand scenes, ideas, or processes more easily than descriptions alone.
    • Example: Friend describing Grand Canyon trip vs. showing pictures—visual is more effective.
    • Example: Instruction manuals with pictures of parts help visualize assembly.
  • Multiple purposes:
    • Help audiences understand.
    • Engage attention.
    • Evoke emotional responses.
  • Example: SPCA commercial with Sarah McLachlan blends sound (song), text, and imagery to evoke sympathy and compassion. Images of animals in cages (some abused) evoke strongest reaction.
  • Pathos appeals using imagery aren't always about sympathy:
    • Amusement park: photos of people having fun on rides.
    • Hotel: photos of clean, luxurious rooms and pools.
    • Purpose: create desire in viewers, compelling them to participate.

🎬 Videos and GIFs

  • Like still photos, videos, GIFs, and animations serve multiple purposes.
  • Extremely helpful in conveying information—many people use YouTube for step-by-step demonstrations.
  • Paired with verbal descriptions, videos provide richer details of events or processes.
    • Example: Football games on TV with instant replays, zooming, slow motion, commentators' discussion, and telestration help viewers understand exactly what happened.
  • Highly effective in engaging audiences (YouTube and TikTok popularity).
  • Create emotional connections—perhaps even more than still photos—because they depict detailed scenes with voices and sounds, creating the sense of being in the moment.

📊 Charts and graphs

  • Bar graphs, pie charts, and illustrations clarify ideas or processes.
  • Particularly for numerical data, graphs with colored lines are much easier to process than text filled with numbers.
  • Tables, flow charts, figures, and illustrations help audiences make sense of organized data in visual format.

🤲 Gestural mode: Body language

🤲 What gestural mode includes

  • Meaning interpreted based on speaker's gestures—body movements and facial expressions.
  • Missing in written text and phone conversations—you don't see physical gestures that clarify attitude and implied meaning.

🎭 Importance of gestures

  • Gestures and facial expressions are crucial in helping understand message meaning.
  • Example: Sign language—entirety of message is encoded using physical gestures.
5

Writing the Genres of the Web

5. Writing the Genres of the Web

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

Multimodal communication uses five distinct modes—visual, gestural, spatial, aural, and linguistic—to convey meaning more effectively than text alone, with each mode contributing unique cues that shape how audiences interpret messages.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • Five modes of communication: visual (images, videos, charts), gestural (body language, facial expressions), spatial (layout, arrangement), aural (volume, tone, music), and linguistic (words).
  • Why multimodality matters: combining modes provides richer detail, engages audiences more effectively, and clarifies complex information (e.g., videos with commentary, graphs for numerical data).
  • Gestural cues are crucial but can be misread: facial expressions and body language communicate attitude and mood, but they are often misinterpreted and can evoke similar emotions in the audience.
  • Spatial design influences comprehension: arrangement, proximity, contrast, and repetition determine how easily readers find and process information, and poor layout can make understanding difficult.
  • Common confusion—aural vs linguistic: aural mode is not just the words spoken (linguistic) but the volume, tone, pitch, rhythm, music, and sound effects that allow audiences to interpret the full meaning of those words.

📸 Visual mode: images, videos, and data displays

📹 Videos for rich detail and engagement

Videos convey information through step-by-step demonstrations, paired with verbal descriptions and instructions, providing richer details of an event or process.

  • Videos are especially effective when showing processes or events that benefit from motion and sound.
  • Example: Football game instant replays use slow motion, zooming, commentators' discussion, and telestration to help viewers understand exactly what happened in a play.
  • Videos engage audiences powerfully (YouTube, TikTok) and create emotional connections by depicting detailed scenes, voices, and sounds, giving viewers the sense they are "right there in the moment."
  • Don't confuse: videos are more than just moving pictures—they combine visual detail with sound and narration to deepen understanding.

📊 Charts and graphs for clarity

Bar graphs, pie charts, and illustrations clarify ideas or processes, especially when presenting numerical data.

  • A graph or chart with colored lines is much easier for viewers to process than text filled with numbers.
  • Tables, flow charts, figures, and illustrations also help audiences make sense of data when organized in a visual format.
  • Why it matters: audiences are more likely to understand and retain information presented visually rather than as strings of numbers in text.

🤲 Gestural mode: body language and physical cues

👋 Hand gestures for direct communication

Hand gestures allow meaning to be interpreted based on body movements and facial expressions, an aspect missing in written text and phone conversations.

  • Simple cues like pointing or thumbs-up communicate information quickly.
  • Example: Scuba divers use hand gestures underwater—thumbs-up means "need to go to the surface," flat hand across throat means "out of air."
  • Sign language uses hand gestures with its own grammar, varying by region, to communicate a full range of ideas.

😊 Facial expressions and their risks

  • Facial expressions communicate attitude or mood; a wink signals a joke, a raised eyebrow indicates surprise or suspicion.
  • Important caveat: facial expressions are often misread—a frown might be misunderstood as anger or sadness when the person is just concentrating.
  • Facial expressions can evoke similar emotions in the audience, amplifying the emotional impact of a message.

🧍 Body language as attitude signals

  • Posture, stance, proximity to others, and body movements signal attitude, feelings, and reactions.
  • Example: Students sitting up front, taking notes, raising hands, and nodding signal positive attitude toward the teacher and class; students at the back, arms folded, eyes on phones, signal the opposite.
  • Why it matters: body language makes the first impression and can build your image positively or negatively; it's easier to communicate with someone whose body language shows receptiveness.

🗺️ Spatial mode: layout and design choices

📐 Arrangement of elements

The spatial mode relates to the spacing and overall layout of a document and the connections this implies to readers.

  • Even basic black text on white has an arrangement that influences the order in which readers take in information.
  • Obvious choices: title at the top, sections separated by space.
  • Less obvious: where to place pictures, charts, videos, social media icons, and multiple text sections on a web page.
  • Good arrangement aids viewers' ability to find and process information easily; poor arrangement makes it much more difficult.
  • Many websites are "responsive," shifting layout for mobile users so information remains easy to read on smaller screens.

🔗 Proximity and grouping

  • Elements that go together should be close to each other (e.g., a caption directly underneath a photo).
  • Similar items are grouped together (e.g., navigation menu items, bulleted lists).
  • Additional white space separates items that don't go together, signifying a transition or distinction.

🎨 Contrast and repetition for emphasis

Design principleWhat it doesHow to use it
ContrastDraws viewer's attention to a focal pointUse opposing colors, sizes, shapes, textures, or white space to set elements apart or highlight key takeaways while maintaining overall aesthetic
RepetitionCreates uniformity and brandingUse the same element (e.g., 2–5 color palette, shapes, textures) over and over; too many variations create chaos and nothing is emphasized effectively
  • Repetition is often seen across a family of publications by the same organization, establishing branding and familiarity with the audience.

🔊 Aural mode: sounds that shape meaning

🔉 Volume, tone, and pitch

The aural mode refers to the many different sounds that bring meaning to a message, beyond the actual words (linguistic mode).

  • Volume: Louder volume implies urgency and importance; yelling signals excitement (anger, fear, happiness); low whisper suggests something personal or secretive.
  • Tone: Reveals attitude toward information—sarcasm means the opposite of what is said; tone shows if someone is joking, excited, somber, or serious.
  • Pitch: How high or low a speaker's voice is; intentionally changing pitch across a range engages the audience, emphasizes ideas, communicates emotion, or signals a transition.

🎵 Rhythm and music for emotional impact

  • Rhythm: The speed and pattern of stressed/unstressed syllables; faster rhythm is energetic and happier, slower rhythm is sad, soothing, or sentimental; disrupting the pattern emphasizes certain words and ideas.
  • Music: Has a significant effect on a person's mood and emotional reactions—upbeat music energizes and sparks positive mood, slower songs spark sadness or nostalgia.
  • Example: Climactic movie scenes pair songs with action (upbeat for triumph, crescendoing for reunion); SPCA commercial with "Angel" reinforces sadness and compels viewers to take action.
  • Why it matters: pairing an appropriate song to fit an occasion or underlying purpose can have a powerful effect.

🎧 Sound effects for intensity

  • Digital editing tools include standard sound effects or allow custom uploads.
  • Some sound effects are hokey (cartoon "bing," "bang," "pow"), but others intensify scenes and sway emotional reactions.
  • Example: Laugh tracks in sitcoms signal that a scene is meant to be funny, guiding audience interpretation.
6

Multimodality in Communication

6. Basic Design Principles

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

Multimodality—the strategic combination of linguistic, visual, aural, and gestural elements—enhances communication by engaging audiences more fully and clarifying meaning, but requires intentional design focused on audience and purpose rather than simply layering as many modes as possible.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • All communication is multimodal: even simple text or phone calls combine multiple modes (e.g., text includes font and color; speech includes tone and pauses).
  • More modes enable richer interpretation: in-person conversations are preferred for important topics because multiple cues make meaning easier and quicker to interpret.
  • Common confusion: multimodality is not limited to digital media—printed materials and face-to-face conversations are also multimodal.
  • Strategic use matters more than quantity: effective multimodal messages require intentional selection of modes that work toward a clear purpose, not overwhelming the audience with every available tool.
  • Rhetorical focus is essential: the best multimodal design considers the intended audience, their expectations, and the underlying purpose of the message.

🎵 Aural modes and emotional impact

🎶 Rhythm

The pattern of stressed and unstressed syllables that creates rhythm.

  • Rhythm controls the speed at which a speaker moves through text and engages audiences who "move to the beat."
  • Faster rhythm: more energetic, tends to convey happiness.
  • Slower rhythm: often more sad, soothing, or sentimental.
  • Beyond emotion, rhythm emphasizes certain words and ideas, especially when the pattern is disrupted.

🎼 Music

  • Music significantly affects a person's mood and emotional reactions.
  • Upbeat music: energizes and sparks positive mood.
  • Slower music: sparks feelings of sadness or nostalgia.
  • Example: climactic movie scenes pair songs with action (triumphant songs for victories, crescendoing songs for reunions); charity commercials use emotional songs to reinforce sadness and compel action.
  • Pairing appropriate music to fit an occasion or message purpose creates powerful effects.

🔊 Sound effects

  • Digital editing tools provide standard sound effects or allow custom uploads.
  • Can intensify scenes and sway emotional reactions beyond simple cartoon effects.
  • Example: laugh tracks in sitcoms signal humor and compel viewers to join in; movies and plays use train whistles, footsteps, door slams, and gunshots to add clarity and engage audiences in the plot.

⏸️ Pauses

  • Strategic silence can be as powerful as words and sound effects.
  • Pauses build suspense as audiences wait to see what happens next.
  • Example: the long silence following a gunshot allows thoughts and emotions to occur; pauses during speeches engage attention.

🌐 The inherent multimodality of all messages

📝 Text-based messages

  • Include not only the linguistic mode but also visual elements:
    • Font
    • Color
    • Formatting

📞 Verbal messages

  • Include the linguistic mode along with aural elements:
    • Volume
    • Pitch
    • Tone
    • Meaningful pauses

👋 Gestural messages

  • Even a simple wave includes other visual elements:
    • Speed of the gesture
    • Context of surroundings

🚫 Don't confuse

Multimodality is not limited to the digital realm—in-person conversations and printed materials are equally multimodal.

💬 Why in-person communication is preferred

✅ Advantages of face-to-face

  • Easier and quicker interpretation: with a range of linguistic, audiovisual, and gestural cues, audiences can interpret meaning more fully because more cues are present.
  • Natural conversation flow: visual and gestural cues help signal when one person's turn is over and another's begins.

💻 Digital alternatives and limitations

ToolCapabilitiesSignificant limitations
Zoom, Google MeetSimulate face-to-face with facial expressions and gestures; screen sharing adds pictures, text, videosParticipants aren't in shared space; can't fully see each other; sound/video quality problems interfere
Video conferencing generallySynchronous audiovisual communicationMinor lag disrupts normal flow and makes reading signals harder

😫 Zoom fatigue

  • Following the COVID-19 pandemic, many complained of fatigue related to:
    • Facial expressions under constant focus
    • Need to rely on exaggerated gestures to convey meaning

🎯 Strategic multimodal design

🎨 Intentional combination

  • While all messages automatically rely on multiple modes, understanding multimodality allows intentional combination to:
    • Engage audiences
    • Clarify meaning
    • Compel action
  • Digital tools now make professional editing accessible (video editing, voice overs, music, text overlays, animation).
  • What sets effective messages apart: the way multimodal elements are layered to create one coherent message working toward a clear purpose.

🎭 Multimodal rhetoric

"Functions and structures realized by and constructed in the strategic conjunction of several semiotic modes, which ultimately carry rhetorical action."

  • Focus on rhetoric: the intended audience and underlying purpose(s).
  • Key questions to ask:
    • What do you hope the audience will do or think as a result?
    • What tools are available in the given situation (in person or online)?
    • Which tools would enhance the message vs. which would be a distraction or deterrence?

⚠️ Avoid overwhelming audiences

  • Layering as many modes as possible is not a strategy.
  • Too many modes overwhelm audiences and make it difficult to attend to all the different signals.
  • Effective design requires predicting audience questions and reactions, focusing on their expectations.
  • Strategy involves selecting modes that work together coherently rather than adding everything available.
7

Multimodality as a Rhetorical Tool

7. Accessibility and Inclusion

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

Multimodality becomes most effective when you intentionally combine modes with a rhetorical focus on audience, purpose, and the strategic layering of elements to create one coherent, persuasive message.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • Intentionality matters: all messages use multiple modes automatically, but understanding multimodality lets you deliberately combine modes to engage audiences, clarify meaning, and compel action.
  • Rhetoric drives choices: the best approach focuses on the intended audience, the underlying purpose, and what you want the audience to think or do.
  • Strategic layering, not overload: piling on as many modes as possible is not a strategy—it overwhelms audiences; effective messages require careful selection and combination.
  • Common confusion: more modes ≠ better communication; the key is choosing which modes align with your goals and audience expectations, not maximizing quantity.
  • Digital tools expand possibilities: professional-grade tools are now widely accessible for editing video, adding voiceovers, music, and text, making multimodal creation easier than ever.

🎯 Thinking rhetorically about multimodality

🎯 Audience and purpose first

Multimodal rhetoric: "functions and structures realized by and constructed in the strategic conjunction of several semiotic modes, which ultimately carry rhetorical action."

  • The excerpt emphasizes starting with two questions:
    • Who is the audience?
    • What do you hope they will do or think as a result of your message?
  • You must predict audience questions and reactions, then choose modes that will be most effective in engaging their attention and helping them understand.
  • Example: deciding a photo is appropriate is not enough—you must determine what type of picture will resonate with the audience's experiences, values, and perspectives.

🧰 Available tools and constraints

  • Consider what tools are available in a given situation (in-person or online).
  • Ask: which tools would enhance your message, and which might distract or deter?
  • The excerpt warns that layering as many modes as possible "would overwhelm an audience and make it difficult for them to attend to all of the different signals available."
  • Don't confuse: availability of tools with effectiveness—just because you can add a mode doesn't mean you should.

🧩 Key rhetorical considerations

🧩 Genre conventions

  • Each genre has its own set of standards that align with audience expectations.
  • Example: a TikTok viewer expects a short video; an Instagram user expects vivid and interesting photos.
  • Matching genre conventions helps meet audience expectations and increases engagement.

🎨 Mode-goal alignment

  • Different modes work better for different goals:
    • Complex content: pair spoken words with bulleted text, charts, and images to aid understanding.
    • Persuasion: consider whether a well-developed argument, a photo, a bar graph, or all three will be most compelling.
  • The excerpt stresses thinking about "the types of content … that will be the most compelling" for your specific goal.

💬 Rhetorical appeals and modes

AppealHow modes support itExample from excerpt
LogosWritten and spoken words often work wellLogical arguments conveyed through text or speech
EthosCan be built through various modes(Not detailed in excerpt)
PathosImages and music are often more effectiveEmotional connection through visuals and sound
  • The excerpt notes: "As you integrate different types of content using various modes, you can strengthen the persuasive effect of your message in powerful ways."
  • Depending on content, genre, and audience, one appeal might be more appropriate than another.
  • Don't confuse: all modes can theoretically support any appeal, but certain modes are more effective for specific appeals.

🛠️ Platform affordances and resources

  • Platform constraints: sometimes the affordances and constraints of a particular application will dictate some choices.
  • Resource availability:
    • Do you have high-resolution photos or quality footage?
    • Do you have the means to obtain or create these media?
    • The excerpt advises: "it's always better to use high-quality, original materials than stock photos or something low-quality."
  • You can only work with what you have, so resource assessment is a practical rhetorical consideration.

🚀 Digital tools and multimodal creation

🚀 Accessibility of professional tools

  • The excerpt highlights that "more than ever before, professional tools are available to the masses to plan, create, edit, and disseminate multimodal messages."
  • Digital tools allow you to:
    • Quickly and easily edit video
    • Create voice overs
    • Add music or snippets of text to video or animation
  • This democratization of tools means technical capability is no longer the main barrier.

🎯 What sets effective messages apart

  • With so many people having access to the same tools, what distinguishes an effective message from one that gets "swiped"?
  • The excerpt's answer: "the way that multimodal elements are layered to create one coherent message that works toward a clear purpose."
  • Strategy and intentionality matter more than technical sophistication alone.

🧠 Strategic thinking framework

🧠 Creative combination

  • The main idea is to "think creatively and about how different modes might be combined to convey a message, to persuade your target audience, and to compel action."
  • Truly effective digital communication utilizes a variety of communication tools, requiring:
    • A deeper understanding of the rhetorical situation
    • Knowledge of the most appropriate means of persuasion
  • This is not about following set rules—the excerpt states "there aren't any set rules on how to combine multimodal elements to create an effective message."

🧠 Coherence over quantity

  • The excerpt repeatedly emphasizes creating "one coherent message."
  • Coherence comes from strategic selection and layering, not from maximizing the number of modes used.
  • Example: if you decide to use a photo, spoken words, and background music, each element should reinforce the same message rather than pulling the audience in different directions.
8

Purpose of Narration

8. Purpose of Narration

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

Genre conventions are recurring features that define different types of writing, and following these conventions enhances readability, credibility, and effectiveness by meeting audience expectations and facilitating the social purposes that each genre serves.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • What a genre is: a category of writing distinguished by particular qualities, style, form, and content that correspond to specific purposes and audience expectations.
  • What genre conventions are: defining features that help readers easily understand what a text is and how it should be read, making communication more effective.
  • Social function of genres: genres emerge to meet specific communication needs and facilitate human relationships and activities; conventions develop because audiences expect certain patterns.
  • Common confusion: genres might seem limiting, but they actually enhance creativity and critical thinking by providing productive parameters that guide meaningful writing.
  • Why conventions matter: following conventions builds credibility, improves readability through familiar patterns, and increases the likelihood of favorable audience response.

🎯 Understanding genre as a category

📚 What defines a genre

Genre: a category of writing that can be distinguished because it has certain qualities, particular style, form, or content.

  • Not limited to artistic or literary composition—everyday writing like text messages and résumés are also genres.
  • Each genre has defining qualities that separate it from other writing styles.
  • Example: You can identify music genres (country, rap, heavy metal) quickly based on melody, instruments, and lyrics; similarly, writing genres have recognizable features.

🔄 Genres beyond literature

The excerpt expands the traditional definition beyond artistic writing:

  • Text messages: use emojis, acronyms, GIFs, short conversational messages; less formal; reserved for close family and friends.
  • Résumés: formal tone, specific format, particular information types; no emojis or text acronyms.
  • Web genres: variety of formats with specific features corresponding to particular purposes and audience expectations.

Don't confuse: Genre is not just about literature or art—it applies to all types of communication, including everyday digital writing.

🔧 Genre conventions explained

🧩 What a convention is

Genre convention: a particular feature that is definitive of a genre, helping readers to easily understand what it is and how it should be read.

  • Conventions are the specific, repeated elements that make a genre recognizable.
  • They include formatting, tone, organizational structure, and content itself.
  • A single genre often includes several conventions working together.

🤝 The social function of conventions

The excerpt emphasizes that genre is "inherently social":

  • Why genres exist: New genres emerge alongside new technologies and new ways of interacting with people.
  • Social need: Genre is "a form of writing with set functions determined by its social need."
  • Typified rhetorical action: Certain features are repeated across genres "because audiences expect certain things to happen or they want certain kinds of experiences."
  • Evolution: Genres that continue to address specific needs remain in use; those replaced by better options (like handwritten letters vs. digital messages) decline.

Example: A grocery list developed from the need to remember many items, so the bulleted format emerged to quickly and easily identify what to purchase.

📋 How conventions aid the reader experience

Following conventions helps in multiple ways:

BenefitHow it works
Easier comprehensionFamiliar patterns let readers quickly pick out main ideas
Faster processingReaders can scan and locate key information efficiently
Clear expectationsAudiences know what to expect and how to interpret the text
Better retentionStandard formats reduce cognitive load, making content more memorable

🚫 When conventions are broken

⚠️ The grocery list example

The excerpt illustrates why conventions matter by showing what happens when they're violated:

  • Standard grocery list: Each item on a separate line, bulleted, just the item name.
  • Broken convention: Everything running together like a paragraph, written in sentence form with explanations.
  • Result:
    • Incredibly difficult to pick out items
    • Takes a long time to read
    • High chance of missing items
    • Fails the social function (quick reference while shopping)

This example shows that conventions aren't arbitrary—they directly support the purpose of the genre.

📄 The résumé example

The excerpt uses résumés to demonstrate typical conventions:

Common résumé conventions:

  • Black type with legible font (Arial or Times New Roman)
  • Name and contact information at the top
  • Clear headings: professional experience, education, special skills, references
  • Short length, typically one page

Why these conventions work:

  • Make it easier to quickly highlight key qualifications
  • Make it easier to write (formatting and basic content already established)
  • Make it easier for employers to scan and pick out key information
  • Support the decision-making process

Don't confuse: While content is personal and layout may vary slightly, basic conventions remain consistent across all résumés.

💡 Why following conventions matters

🎨 Enhances creativity, not limits it

The excerpt addresses a counterintuitive point:

  • Common assumption: Genres create parameters that limit creative options.
  • Reality: Genres provide a productive lens that guides writing and thinking.
  • How it works: Genres are created to meet particular purposes responding to certain exigencies; focusing on conventions enhances ability to write something meaningful.

🏆 Three key benefits of following conventions

🔍 Improved readability

  • Adheres to writing patterns readers are familiar with
  • Readers can more easily pick out main ideas
  • Reduces confusion and cognitive effort

🧠 Greater creativity and critical thinking

  • Provides productive parameters that guide the writing process
  • Focuses attention on meaningful content
  • Helps respond effectively to rhetorical situations

✅ Increased credibility

  • Signals experience in the genre
  • Demonstrates attention to audience needs and expectations
  • Shows expertise and attention to detail
  • Sparks goodwill and generosity in the audience

Even conventions that seem relatively minor contribute to demonstrating expertise.

🌐 Application to web genres

🔗 Genre selection and rhetorical situation

The excerpt explains the relationship between genre choice and rhetoric:

  • Purpose and audience: Selection of genre and choice to follow conventions relate directly to purpose and audience.
  • Audience receptivity: The audience is more receptive to a message when it follows conventional patterns they are familiar with.
  • When to deviate: While there might be occasions to stray from particular conventions in specific rhetorical situations, following accepted standards is generally beneficial.

📊 Web writing diversity

The excerpt notes that "not all web writing is the same":

  • Writing strategies and accepted standards differ depending on what you are writing.
  • There are a variety of web genres with specific features that help distinguish one from another.
  • Features correspond with particular purposes and audience expectations.

The excerpt promises to examine common web genres (websites, blogs, social media posts, email campaigns) in detail, though the substantive content about these specific genres is not included in this excerpt.

🎓 Learning new genre conventions

The excerpt suggests an approach for encountering unfamiliar genres:

  • You will likely struggle at first to understand conventions
  • Cultivating awareness of genre helps make the transition
  • Understanding underlying reasons for conventions aids the writing and revision processes
  • Focus on how conventions aid reader experience and meet social needs

Don't confuse: Following conventions doesn't mean rigid copying—it means understanding the social function and adapting appropriately to the rhetorical situation.

9

Writing a Narrative

9. Writing a Narrative

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

Understanding genre conventions—the patterns of formatting, tone, structure, and content that define different types of writing—enhances readability, credibility, and effectiveness because it aligns your writing with audience expectations and the social purposes genres are designed to fulfill.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • What genre conventions are: patterns including formatting, tone, organizational structure, and content that make a genre distinct and help readers quickly identify and process information.
  • Why conventions matter: they increase readability (familiar patterns help readers find main ideas), enable creativity (parameters guide thinking), and boost credibility (signals expertise and attention to audience needs).
  • Email types and purposes: work-related emails (brief, friendly, to-the-point) vs. marketing emails (targeted campaigns with clear subject lines, preview text, CTAs).
  • Website core function: serves as the "front door" and center of a digital ecosystem, with other tools (blogs, social media, emails) guiding users back to the website.
  • Common confusion: genres seem to limit creativity, but they actually provide a productive lens that guides writing toward meaningful responses to specific purposes and audiences.

📝 Understanding genre conventions

📝 What conventions include

Genre conventions: patterns that make a genre distinct, including formatting, tone, organizational structure, and the content itself.

  • Conventions are not arbitrary rules; they reflect the underlying reason for how a genre works and how it aids the reader experience.
  • Example: A résumé uses specific formatting (sections, bullet points) so employers familiar with the genre can quickly scan and pick out key information for decision-making.
  • Conventions span multiple elements:
    • Formatting (layout, visual structure)
    • Tone (level of formality)
    • Organizational structure (how information is sequenced)
    • Content (what information is included or excluded)

🔍 How to recognize conventions

  • When you encounter a new genre, you will likely struggle at first to understand what the conventions are and how to adapt your writing.
  • Cultivating awareness of genre helps you make this transition during writing and revision.
  • Example: Make a list of genres you write daily (texts, emails, lists, longer documents) and identify which you're familiar with vs. still learning; then list conventions for each (formatting rules, formality, tone, structure, content).

🎯 Why genre conventions enhance writing

🎯 Readability through familiarity

  • Adhering to writing patterns readers are familiar with makes your work more readable.
  • Readers can more easily pick out your main ideas because the structure matches their expectations.
  • Example: If a document follows expected conventions, readers don't waste cognitive effort figuring out how to navigate it.

🎨 Creativity and critical thinking

  • Don't confuse: Genres create parameters, but this does not limit creativity—it actually provides greater opportunity for creativity and deep critical thinking.
  • The reality: a genre is a productive lens that guides your writing and thinking process.
  • In rhetorical terms, genres are created to meet particular purposes that respond to certain exigencies (urgent needs or problems).
  • Focusing on genre conventions enhances your ability to write something meaningful.

🏆 Credibility and expertise

  • Following genre conventions increases your credibility because it signals to readers that:
    • You are experienced in this genre.
    • You have thought about their needs and expectations.
  • Even conventions that seem relatively minor demonstrate your expertise and attention to detail.
  • This sparks goodwill and similar generosity in your audience.

📧 Email genre conventions

📧 General email approach

  • From a rhetorical standpoint, your approach depends on context: who your audience is and the subject of your email.
  • Emails are generally considered more formal than text messages.
  • Should avoid being overly informal or using "texty" language and emojis.

💼 Work-related emails

  • Purpose: communicate with a colleague, client, or vendor.
  • Tone: friendly but to the point.
  • Structure:
    • Fairly brief if possible.
    • Content broken down into individual paragraphs.
    • Bulleted information for enhanced readability.
    • Hyperlinks to websites and other documents pertinent to the conversation.
  • Call to action (CTA): at the end, even if just to invite questions or request a response about a specific issue.

📬 Marketing emails

  • Purpose: part of a targeted campaign; a way of reaching out individually to leads the company has acquired.
  • Context: Companies use lists of current and prospective customers to send targeted emails (information about promotions, new blog posts, event invitations, etc.).
  • Risk: These can get annoying; people will quickly unsubscribe or assign them to spam if they don't find the information useful.
  • Strategy: Be very intentional about the type and amount of content you send; focus on leads that have expressed genuine interest.
ConventionDetailsWhy it matters
Clear subject lineSpecific and catchy, shorter than 60 characters so it doesn't get cut offGrabs attention among hundreds of daily emails; says something specific about the message
Preview textSort of like a subtitle, provides additional information or a different hook, typically 45 characters or lessGives readers more context before opening
Keep it shortA couple of short paragraphsEngages the reader quickly so they understand the value and feel compelled to take action
Clear CTAPrompts readers to click a link (read blog article, get product info, etc.)Draws people to your site; serves as internal marketing tool
Contact informationProfessional signature with sender's name, company logo, phone number, email addressReaders can easily follow up with questions

🌐 Website genre and functionality

🌐 Website as digital ecosystem center

"Your website is the center of your digital ecosystem." (Leland Dieno)

  • Almost all businesses maintain a website as the "front door" to their organization.
  • Before most customers visit a physical space, they go to the website for information (store hours, products, mission, etc.).
  • It's the first impression most people will have about the organization.
  • Other web genres (blogs, social media posts, emails) are often used as collateral marketing tools that guide people back to the website.
  • The website is where users go to find information; if organized well, it creates a clear path to help them learn about the organization and respond positively to the call to action.

🎯 Core purposes of a website

Web development helps you create a clear path for where you want customers to go, how they will get there, and what the goals are for your audience—everything else connects back to your website.

Five key purposes:

  1. Attract visitors: Engage people with the information presented and the overall mission and service provided.
  2. Provide useful content: (The excerpt emphasizes this goes hand in hand with attracting visitors.)
  3. (The excerpt mentions five key purposes but only elaborates on the first two in the provided text.)

🧲 Inbound marketing strategies

Inbound marketing: strategies that web developers and content writers use to draw people to their sites.

  • Contrast with outbound marketing: Outbound tactics push content out to a broad audience (billboards, magazine ads, TV commercials); inbound marketing works harder to identify the wants, needs, and values of the target audience.
  • Approach: Create web content that is relevant to audience expectations, with special consideration for:
    • Users' pain points.
    • Potential search terms (keywords) they might use to find solutions.
  • This makes a website "optimized" so it becomes easier to find and use.

🔍 Optimization tactics

TacticWhat it isWhy it works
Meta descriptionsInformation that appears on the search engine results page (SERP): URL, clickable page title, and a "snippet" of text describing the page contentProviding relevant and interesting information and a call to action makes a website much more likely to attract visitors
Meta tagsTags for other content on the page—titles, alt tags for images and graphics, headersHelps search engines and users understand page content
Google Business ProfileProvides contact information, business hours, customer reviews, and other helpful informationBuilds awareness and credibility; provides a path directly to the website

Don't confuse: Some SEO practices are designed to mislead users. For example, keyword stuffing (repeating keywords and phrases over and over) is an attempt to rank higher on the SERP, but it makes a page look like it has relevant content without actually providing value.

🛠️ Website development scope

  • Website development is a very big topic with many nuances in functionality (which evolve quickly with new integrations and plugin updates) and differences from one platform to the next.
  • Many businesses pay web developing companies thousands of dollars to create and update their website.
  • Advancements in digital tools and user-friendly platforms have made it possible for people to create and maintain their own website—if they are willing to take time to learn how.
  • Numerous resources are available: resource guides for web development, articles comparing website platforms and their pros/cons, YouTube videos from hosting services and experienced users.
  • The textbook's goal: help you think more clearly about the purpose of the website and how to develop content to meet that purpose, plus discuss best practices in website design.
10

Podcast Scripting, Opens, Bumpers, Endings

10. Podcast Scripting, Opens, Bumpers, Endings

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

The excerpt does not contain substantive content about podcast scripting, opens, bumpers, or endings; instead, it discusses website design, SEO practices, and web content strategy.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • The provided excerpt focuses entirely on website development and search engine optimization, not podcast production.
  • No information about podcast scripting techniques, opening segments, bumper creation, or ending formats is present in the source material.
  • The excerpt covers topics such as meta descriptions, keyword strategies, content organization, and calls to action for websites.
  • There is a complete mismatch between the stated title and the actual content of the excerpt.

📄 Content mismatch

📄 What the excerpt actually covers

The source material discusses web content writing and website design principles. It includes:

  • SEO strategies like meta descriptions and meta tags
  • Website functions such as attracting visitors and strengthening brand identity
  • Genre conventions for websites including readability and organization
  • Lead generation and calls to action for web pages

🎙️ What is missing

The excerpt contains no information about:

  • Podcast script structure or writing techniques
  • Opening segments or intro formats for podcasts
  • Bumper content or transitions between podcast segments
  • Ending formats or outro scripts for podcasts
  • Audio production considerations
  • Podcast-specific storytelling or pacing

⚠️ Note for review

⚠️ Source material limitation

This excerpt cannot be used to create meaningful review notes about podcast scripting, opens, bumpers, or endings because it addresses an entirely different topic (website content strategy). To study the stated title topic, a different source excerpt containing relevant podcast production content would be required.

11

What is Argumentation?

11. What is Argumentation?

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

The excerpt provided does not contain substantive content about argumentation; instead, it discusses web writing conventions for websites and blogs.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • The excerpt focuses on web design and content strategy, not argumentation theory.
  • Main topics covered include website organization, readability, hyperlinks, visuals, and calls to action.
  • A brief mention of blogs appears at the end, describing their rhetorical function for organizations.
  • Common confusion: This excerpt does not match the title "What is Argumentation?" and contains no discussion of argumentative concepts, structures, or reasoning.
  • The content is about technical writing for digital platforms, not about constructing or analyzing arguments.

📋 Content mismatch

📋 What the excerpt actually covers

The provided text is from a chapter titled "Writing the Genres of the Web" (pages 50–53). It discusses:

  • How to organize website content through site maps and grouping similar items
  • Strategies for improving readability on web pages
  • The use of hyperlinks, visuals, and design elements
  • Blog purposes for organizations

⚠️ Missing argumentation content

No information about argumentation is present in this excerpt.

The excerpt does not define argumentation, explain argumentative structures, discuss claims and evidence, describe reasoning processes, or cover any related concepts that would be expected under the title "What is Argumentation?"

🌐 Web writing conventions (actual excerpt content)

🗂️ Organization and navigation

Site map: a demonstration of the organizational structure of a site using clear menu labels.

  • The first step is grouping similar items together logically.
  • Tools like Creately.com can help create site maps, or they can be drawn on paper.
  • Clear organization helps visitors find information efficiently.

📖 Readability strategies

Key elements that guide readers through web content:

  • Headings and subheadings
  • Bulleted lists
  • Short paragraphs
  • Simple sentence structures
  • Clear, specific word choice

Formatting choices for readability:

  • Sans serif fonts (easier to read on screens)
  • Bold text for titles and subtitles
  • Larger font sizes for higher-level text
  • Appropriate spacing so items aren't crammed but related items are visually grouped

🔗 Hyperlinks

Hyperlinks: links that help visitors make connections and navigate the site.

Types of links:

Link typePurposeExample use
Internal linksGuide readers to more detailed information on your own siteLinks to relevant pages about specific topics
External linksBuild credibility and provide information without taking up page spaceLinks to credible, relevant external sources
Call-to-action linksIncrease likelihood of user taking desired actionLinks at bottom of page to schedule appointments or get more information

Strategic use:

  • Limit the number of links per page to avoid overwhelming readers.
  • Choose hyperlink text carefully so readers know what to expect when they click.
  • Example: If a fitness blog says "There are many different methods for increasing your stamina during a workout," hyperlinking "different methods" or "increasing your stamina" should lead to information about those methods, not to a product page selling running shoes.
  • Don't confuse: Misleading hyperlink text frustrates users and damages credibility.

🎨 Visuals and design

Purposes of visuals on web pages:

  1. Clarify information: Maps, pie graphs, tables, charts, photos help readers process information more easily.
  2. Support written content: A company selling cars would include pictures of the cars.
  3. Branding: Help visitors understand the personality or mission of a person or organization.
    • Example: A children's hospital would use photos of doctors working with smiling children to demonstrate care and compassion, persuading visitors to bring their children there or donate money.

🎨 Aesthetic elements

Aesthetics of a website: the overall layout with different components, menus, buttons, images, icons, colors, fonts, and interactive features that create a user-friendly appearance.

Design elements that convey meaning:

  • Color choice
  • Font size and design
  • Graphics and images
  • Interactive features (sounds, animations, symbols)

These elements direct readers' attention, help them understand information, affect overall user experience, and develop the organization's ethos.

🎯 Additional web writing principles

🎯 Specificity in content

Be specific: provide clear information that readers are looking for, not vague, flowery text.

  • Visitors look for specific information about products, services, events, pricing, etc.
  • Product descriptions should include:
    • Dimensions
    • Items included
    • Capabilities
    • Other items needed for use
    • Any information helping readers decide whether to buy

Balance needed:

  • Streamline content while providing enough detail.
  • Use available space for meaningful content.
  • Provide opportunities to get more information.

📣 Calls to action

Almost every page has a call to action that explicitly invites users to take the next step:

  • Find out more information
  • Donate money
  • Buy a product
  • Read a full article

These appear as buttons or clear statements with hyperlinks at the bottom of the page.

🔄 Keeping content updated

Why updates matter:

  • Outdated information quickly loses credibility.
  • Broken links or irrelevant information signals that maintaining the website isn't a priority.
  • Outdated calendars (still showing previous months' events) suggest information might not be accurate.

How to keep content fresh:

  • Update information regularly
  • Swap in new pictures or videos
  • Demonstrate an active online presence
  • Show effort to continually engage with target audience

📝 Blogs as a distinct genre

📝 Purpose of organizational blogs

Purpose of a blog: to further develop brand with target audience, strengthen credibility in a particular area of expertise, solidify connections with readers through meaningful content, and increase traffic to the website.

How blogs differ from main website content:

  • Blogs are often housed as part of a larger website and use similar conventions.
  • Their rhetorical function is different from static website pages.
  • Blogs help keep content "fresh" more easily than the main website, since the overall mission and service offerings of an organization don't change frequently.
  • Blogs allow for regular updates and engagement without restructuring the entire site.
12

Rhetoric of Argumentation

12. Rhetoric of Argumentation

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

Websites and blogs serve distinct rhetorical functions—websites establish organizational presence and navigation, while blogs build brand expertise and audience engagement through focused, regularly updated content within a specific niche.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • Website purpose: keep content fresh through updates (pictures, videos) to demonstrate active online presence and continual engagement with target audiences.
  • Blog purpose: develop brand, strengthen credibility, solidify reader connections through meaningful content, and increase website traffic.
  • Niche importance: successful blogs focus on one area of expertise; scattered topics weaken brand and confuse audiences.
  • Common confusion: blogs vs. websites—blogs are often part of a larger website but have a different rhetorical function (ongoing engagement vs. stable information architecture).
  • Niche breadth test: you should be able to generate 10–15 article ideas within your niche; if not, it may be too narrow.

🌐 Website genre conventions

🎨 Keeping content fresh

  • Websites need to demonstrate an active online presence and effort to continually engage the target audience.
  • Since overall mission and service offerings don't change often, updating pictures or videos is a practical way to keep the site fresh.
  • Example: An organization swaps out images seasonally or adds new video testimonials to show ongoing activity without restructuring the entire site.

🗺️ Site navigation and organization

The excerpt describes Activity 13.2, which asks readers to:

  • Identify what an organization does and its mission.
  • Examine how the website develops the organization's brand.
  • Analyze how the site helps visitors navigate.
  • Sketch a site map showing main menu items and secondary/tertiary pages.
  • Evaluate whether content items are organized into similar groupings to ease navigation.

Key takeaway: Effective websites group related content logically and make key information accessible to first-time visitors.

📝 Blog genre and rhetorical function

🎯 Why blogs differ from websites

The purpose of a blog is to further develop brand with the target audience, strengthen credibility in a particular area of expertise, solidify connections with readers through meaningful content, and increase traffic to the website.

  • Blogs are often housed as part of a larger website but serve a different rhetorical function.
  • Websites provide stable information; blogs provide dynamic, regularly updated content (e.g., weekly posts).
  • Blogs drive readers back to the website repeatedly, where they are more likely to follow calls to action (get more information, share posts, buy products).

🔄 Freshness strategy

  • Posting blog articles every week or so keeps content fresh without changing the main website.
  • This strategy offers readers new and relevant information and encourages repeat visits.
  • Don't confuse: website updates (occasional) vs. blog updates (frequent and ongoing).

🎪 The concept of niche

🔍 What niche means

All successful blogs have a particular niche or an area of focus.

  • A niche is a specific topic or field the blog consistently addresses.
  • It builds the brand as an expert in that area and keeps the target audience engaged.
  • Example: Travel bloggers write about travel destinations, tips, and experiences—not suddenly about DIY home projects or gardening.

⚠️ Common mistake: scattered topics

  • Novice bloggers often try to write about many different things, making the blog eclectic and scattered.
  • This might engage immediate family and friends but won't attract other followers.
  • Posting unrelated content (e.g., a travel blog suddenly posting gardening tips) confuses the audience and weakens the brand.

🔗 Aligning niche with brand

Whatever niche you pick should relate directly to your brand—individual or organizational.

Organization typePossible blog nicheHow it supports brand
Hardware storeDIY projects and home repairsShowcases products, develops expertise, drives store visits
DaycareChildhood development and best practicesPositions as expert in child engagement
UniversityStudent success (academics, financial aid, housing)Provides useful content, builds connection with students/parents
Yoga studioYoga techniques, benefits, exercises, principlesAttracts people interested in trying yoga, positions studio as expert
  • Readers get useful information and are more likely to visit the organization or buy products.
  • The blog positions the organization as genuinely interested in helping people be successful.

📏 Balancing niche breadth

📐 Narrow enough vs. broad enough

  • Your niche should be focused (to build expertise) but broad enough to generate lots of new and interesting topics.
  • This allows you to post a new blog article every week or so without running out of ideas.

✅ The 10–15 article test

A good test would be to see whether you can come up with 10–15 article ideas within that niche. If you can't, it might be a sign that your niche is too narrow.

  • Example of too narrow: "window replacement" (limited article ideas).
  • Example of appropriately broad: "DIY" (many possible topics).
  • Example of appropriately broad: "student success" (time management, syllabus decoding, class scheduling, graduation requirements, study skills, internships, etc.).

🧩 Flexibility within niche

  • The university blog example shows how a flexible niche (student success) can generate never-ending specific article topics.
  • This provides meaningful information for multiple audiences: current students, prospective students, and parents.
  • As readers continue to engage with the blog, they develop a deeper connection with the organization.

Don't confuse: A broad niche (e.g., "student success") is not the same as a scattered blog (random unrelated topics); the broad niche still has a clear focus area with many subtopics.

13

Basic Structure and Content of Argument

13. Basic Structure and Content of Argument

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

Blog posts follow specific genre conventions—focused niche, chunked content, concise writing, engaging titles, and credible hyperlinks—all designed to engage readers and persuade them to take action.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • Niche selection: must be focused enough to build brand identity yet broad enough to generate many article topics (test: can you list 10–15 ideas?).
  • Genre conventions serve persuasion: every structural choice (headings, length, links) is rhetorical—it shapes how readers respond.
  • Chunking and conciseness: break content into subsections with clear headings; keep paragraphs short (2–4 sentences) to maintain reader interest.
  • Common confusion: broad vs. narrow niche—"student success" is broad and flexible; "study skills" is too narrow and limits content variety.
  • Credibility through hyperlinks: link to reputable external sources to support claims, but avoid old content, unclear authors, or competing sites that distract readers.

🎯 Choosing the right niche

🎯 What a niche is and why it matters

A niche is a focused topic area that aligns with your brand and provides value to a specific target audience.

  • The niche should reflect what your organization does and what your audience cares about.
  • Example: A hardware store blogs about DIY home improvement; a daycare blogs about childhood development; a yoga studio blogs about yoga techniques and benefits.
  • Why it matters: a focused niche positions you as an expert and builds trust with readers who return for more content.

🔍 Balancing focus and breadth

  • Too narrow: limits the number of articles you can write; readers lose interest if topics repeat.
  • Too broad: dilutes your brand; readers don't see you as a specialist.
  • The test: try to generate 10–15 article ideas within your niche. If you can't, the niche is probably too narrow.
Niche comparisonToo narrowBetter (broader)
University blogStudy skillsStudent success (academics, financial aid, housing, time management, internships)
Home improvementWindow replacementDIY (many project types)
  • Example: A university blog on "student success" can cover time management, syllabus decoding, class scheduling, graduation requirements, exam study tips, internships—endless relevant topics.

🧩 Why flexibility sustains engagement

  • A robust niche lets you post new content regularly (e.g., weekly) without running out of ideas.
  • Readers (current students, prospective students, parents) develop a deeper connection as they engage with varied, meaningful content over time.

📝 Core genre conventions

📝 Stay focused on one main idea

  • Every blog article should clearly relate to your established niche and deliver on the promise made in the title and introduction.
  • Length varies (300–2,000 words), but all content should develop one key idea valuable to your target audience.
  • Avoid unnecessary tangents; longer posts may add background or elaborate on subpoints, but everything must work together.

🧱 Chunk your content with clear headings

  • Break the article into subsections with descriptive headings so readers can follow the structure easily.
  • Example: A blog on "cognitive benefits of yoga" might include:
    • Brief hook about physical benefits
    • Transition to cognitive benefits
    • Section: "What Is Cognition"
    • Subsections: "Improved Memory," "Better Focus," "Enhanced Problem-Solving"
  • Each subsection has 3–5 short paragraphs focused on that subtopic.
  • Why it works: headings categorize content, making it easier to scan and digest.

✂️ Be concise

  • Keep paragraphs short: 2–4 sentences each.
  • Use bullets when appropriate; use simple sentence structures; eliminate unnecessary words.
  • Don't confuse: adding words to hit a target word count ≠ adding fluff. Instead, add examples, statistics, or descriptions that add meaning and keep readers interested.
  • Blog posts should be consistent in length from one post to the next, but every word should serve a purpose.

🎣 Engaging readers through titles and links

🎣 Have an engaging, specific title

An engaging title clearly states the value proposition—what readers will gain from the article.

  • Specific titles attract more readers than vague or obscure ones.
  • Example:
    • Good: "Ten Best Travel Destinations on the East Coast" (clear benefit: discover top destinations)
    • Good: "Reduce Your Debt in Three Easy Steps" (clear benefit: actionable debt reduction)
  • Readers know exactly what the article is about and how they will benefit.

🔗 Use hyperlinks to build credibility

  • External links: connect to credible sources that support your ideas (recent studies, reputable organizations, well-known experts, recent news articles).
  • What to avoid:
    • Old content or sources with unclear authorship
    • Websites with clear financial motives or bias
    • Competing blogs or company sites that might steal readers' focus
  • Internal links: link to relevant information on your own website or previous blog articles, but use sparingly to avoid appearing self-promotional or disingenuous.
  • Why it matters: transparency about sources enhances your credibility and positions you as a trustworthy expert, even as you build your own brand.
Link typePurposeCaution
External credibleSupport claims; show researchAvoid old, biased, or unclear sources
External competing(Avoid)Distracts readers; undermines your brand
InternalGuide readers to related contentUse sparingly; too much feels self-promotional
14

Understanding and Composing Researched Arguments

14. Understanding and Composing Researched Arguments

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

Effective digital writing requires understanding and applying genre-specific conventions—such as conciseness, engaging titles, hyperlinks, and calls to action—that vary across blogs, social media posts, and other web platforms to engage target audiences and achieve communication goals.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • Genre conventions shape digital writing: Each digital format (blogs, social media, emails) has specific expectations for structure, tone, length, and visual elements that writers must follow.
  • Conciseness is universal: Across all digital platforms, eliminating unnecessary words and using simple structures keeps readers engaged in a scrolling, distraction-filled environment.
  • Platform-specific adaptation matters: Content appropriate for LinkedIn differs from Instagram or X; matching platform conventions and audience expectations is crucial for credibility.
  • Common confusion: More words ≠ better content—adding "fluff" to hit word counts weakens writing; instead, add meaningful examples, statistics, or descriptions.
  • Strategic consistency drives engagement: Organizations use content calendars, content buckets, and regular posting schedules to maintain audience connection and brand presence.

✍️ Blog writing conventions

📝 Core blog characteristics

Blogs occupy a middle ground between formal website content and casual social media posts. They allow organizations to:

  • Demonstrate expertise in a particular area
  • Build brand identity through consistent voice
  • Drive traffic to main websites
  • Engage readers with longer-form content than social media allows

🎯 Engaging, specific titles

Blog titles engage readers because they are clear about the value proposition—the thing that readers will gain from reading the article.

  • Titles should tell readers exactly what they'll learn and how they'll benefit
  • Example: "Ten Best Travel Destinations on the East Coast" or "Reduce Your Debt in Three Easy Steps" are specific and clear
  • Avoid vague or obscure titles that don't communicate value
  • Don't confuse: A clever title without clarity is less effective than a straightforward one that promises specific value

🔗 Hyperlinks and credibility

The excerpt emphasizes two types of links:

Link typePurposeGuidelines
ExternalBuild credibility by citing sourcesLink to recent studies, reputable organizations, well-known experts, recent news; avoid old content, unclear authorship, biased sites, or competing blogs
InternalConnect readers to related content on your siteUse sparingly to avoid appearing self-promotional or disingenuous
  • Transparency about information sources enhances your credibility as an expert
  • The key criterion is "credible"—not just any source will do

💬 Conversational yet professional tone

  • Blogs are generally less formal than main website content
  • This freedom allows writers to be more conversational and build rapport with readers
  • A conversational tone is more accessible—avoid jargon and complex sentences that seem pretentious
  • Language can be lighthearted and fun while maintaining professionalism
  • Focus on the main idea and provide relevant information
  • Context matters: First person is appropriate for personal blogs but may be too informal for organizational blogs

🖼️ Visual elements and proofreading

  • Pictures relevant to content engage readers and deepen understanding
  • Charts, tables, and graphics break up text effectively
  • Despite informality, maintain standards for grammar, spelling, capitalization, and punctuation
  • Proofreading errors distract readers and diminish author credibility

🔄 Dynamic updates and CTAs

  • Blogs should be dynamic with new content added consistently (every couple of weeks)
  • Date your posts to show freshness
  • Regular updates are crucial for reader engagement, branding, increased traffic, and the customer journey
  • End with a call to action (CTA) directing readers to next steps, usually via hyperlink
  • Many companies use boilerplate information at the bottom of articles—repeated word-for-word content about mission, services, and contact resources

📱 Social media post conventions

🎯 Strategic platform selection

Organizations don't create accounts on every platform; instead they:

  • Research which social media sites are most popular with their target audience
  • Understand how certain demographics use which platforms
  • Example: A yoga studio targeting women in their thirties and forties would focus on platforms that demographic uses most

Don't confuse: Having presence everywhere vs. strategic presence where your audience actually is—the latter is more effective.

📅 Consistency through planning

Another key aspect of social media marketing is consistency.

Organizations maintain engagement through:

Planning toolPurposeHow it works
Social media calendarPlan content for the next monthPromotes upcoming events, reports organizational news
Content bucketsEnsure variety in post typesDifferent categories (employee profiles, customer testimonials, product highlights, expert tips) filled throughout the month
  • Some businesses post daily to continuously engage customers
  • Planning ensures meaningful content rather than random posts
  • Variety from day to day keeps audiences interested

🔧 Platform-appropriate content

  • Content must match the platform's overall theme and format
  • LinkedIn focuses on professional advancement and career opportunities—wouldn't be appropriate for yoga techniques
  • X and Facebook are text-based; Instagram focuses on photos; YouTube is for videos
  • Don't confuse: Standing out positively vs. creating confusion—inappropriate content for a platform weakens credibility

✂️ Universal social media best practices

✂️ Extreme conciseness

  • Readers continuously scroll through feeds—catch attention immediately
  • Communicate main idea in a sentence or two
  • X limits characters per post, pushing maximum brevity
  • Other platforms collapse longer posts behind "read more"—readers often don't click, and if they do, they quickly abandon "walls of text"

#️⃣ Hashtags and discoverability

  • Use two or three hashtags (indicated by #) to connect content to groups and reach larger audiences
  • Avoid overdoing it with 7–10 hashtags
  • Most platforms let you research popular hashtags for appropriate use

🏷️ Titles and images

  • Individual posts don't usually have titles, but professional posts often do
  • Titles focus attention and provide value proposition (like blog titles)
  • Appealing images increase likelihood readers will engage
  • Example: A travel agency posting "Affordable Beach Bungalows" would garner more interest with tropical pictures of happy vacationers
  • Short videos and influencer testimonials also grab attention

🔗 Full URLs and CTAs

  • Social media platforms don't use hyperlinks in text (unless you have a button)
  • Give the full URL if linking to a website
  • Include a call to action for people to learn more, often linking to website or email

🤝 Active engagement

  • Respond to comments, questions, and reviews (even if not every single one)
  • Your presence creates positive impression of genuine interest in connecting
  • Intentionally connect with complementary organizations in your community
  • They'll be more compelled to follow, like, and share your posts in return

🔍 Understanding genre as a concept

🧩 Genre beyond specific formats

The excerpt acknowledges it doesn't cover every digital writing genre—there are too many. Genre complexity increases when considering:

  • Specialized fields with their own conventions
  • Different types within broader categories (e.g., university websites vs. restaurant websites vs. charity websites)
  • Narrowed genres like fitness blogs or churches' Facebook posts

🔎 Learning unfamiliar genres

When confronted with an unfamiliar genre:

  1. Gather information from other examples in that genre
  2. Evaluate which elements seem to define it
  3. Look for patterns in:
    • Types of content
    • Graphic elements
    • Tone of voice
    • Design elements
    • Organizational structures

Once you understand the concept of genre, then you can evaluate new forms of writing and apply those genre conventions with confidence.

This approach allows writers to adapt to new contexts without explicit instruction for every possible format.

15

15. Failures in Evidence: When "Lots of Quotes" Can't Save a Paper

15. Failures in Evidence: When“Lots of Quotes”Can’t Save a Paper

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

The excerpt provided contains no substantive content related to the title "Failures in Evidence: When 'Lots of Quotes' Can't Save a Paper"; instead, it consists entirely of discussion questions, source citations, and concluding remarks from a chapter about digital writing genres.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • The excerpt does not address evidence failures, quotation misuse, or academic paper writing.
  • The content focuses on digital writing genres (websites, blogs, social media) and their conventions.
  • Discussion questions emphasize understanding genre conventions and their rhetorical functions.
  • The source list references articles about web design, SEO, content strategy, and social media marketing.
  • There is a mismatch between the given title and the actual excerpt content.

📄 What the excerpt actually contains

📝 Discussion questions about genre

The excerpt includes nine discussion questions covering:

  • Definition and purpose of genre conventions
  • How genre understanding improves writing
  • Rhetorical functions of websites and blogs
  • Social media marketing strategies
  • Application of genre conventions to new writing forms

📚 Source citations

The excerpt provides a bibliography of approximately 20+ sources from:

  • Marketing and social media platforms (Sproutsocial.com, Hubspot.com)
  • Web design and SEO resources (BigCommerce.com, Backlinko.com)
  • Business and technology publications (Entrepreneur.com)
  • Google developer documentation

🔚 Concluding remarks

The excerpt includes a brief note stating:

  • Digital writing has too many genres to cover comprehensively
  • Specialized fields have unique genre conventions (e.g., university websites differ from restaurant websites)
  • Writers can learn unfamiliar genres by studying examples and identifying common elements

⚠️ Content mismatch note

⚠️ Title vs. actual content

The title suggests the excerpt will discuss:

  • How excessive quotations fail to support arguments
  • Evidence quality problems in academic papers
  • When quantity of citations cannot substitute for quality of reasoning

However, the excerpt contains none of these topics. It appears to be the end matter (discussion questions and references) from a textbook chapter on digital writing genres, with no connection to academic argumentation or evidence evaluation.

16

Reflective Writing

16. Reflective Writing

🧭 Overview

🧠 One-sentence thesis

Creating accessible and inclusive digital content requires intentional design practices that accommodate disabilities and welcome diverse identities, benefiting both organizations and the broader community.

📌 Key points (3–5)

  • Accessibility vs. inclusion: Accessibility provides technical strategies (alt text, captions, contrast) for people with disabilities; inclusion addresses broader representation and assumptions about identity.
  • Why it matters: Both have financial, social, and ethical implications—61% of Americans value diversity in marketing, and inaccessible content excludes people with disabilities who represent significant purchasing power.
  • DEI framework: Diversity (representing varied identities), Equity (policies ensuring participation), and Inclusion (active involvement in decision-making) form a comprehensive approach beyond surface-level representation.
  • Common confusion: Targeting a specific audience is not the same as being exclusive—you can focus on women's athletic gear while still representing women of all races, abilities, and body types within that target.
  • Implementation requires humility: Inclusive content demands intentional research, diverse voices, careful language choices, and willingness to learn from mistakes.

♿ Accessibility fundamentals

♿ What accessibility means

Making digital content accessible means ensuring people with disabilities can engage with web content.

  • Accessibility is a subset of the larger concept of inclusion.
  • It focuses on removing barriers for people with various disabilities (visual, auditory, motor, cognitive).
  • The excerpt emphasizes that accessibility provides "very tangible and specific strategies" like color contrast, alt text, and closed captioning.

📋 Standards and guidelines

  • WCAG (Web Content Accessibility Guidelines): The standard for accessibility practices, maintained by the W3C Web Accessibility Initiative.
  • WCAG defines "sufficient" (necessary) and "advisory" (recommended but not required) practices.
  • Section 508: U.S. Access Board guidelines based on the Rehabilitation Act.
  • These standards provide measurable criteria (e.g., contrast ratios, keyboard navigation requirements).

🔍 Five quick accessibility checks

The excerpt provides a practical checklist for auditing websites:

CheckWhat to verifyHow to test
Alt textImages have descriptive textRight-click image, select "inspect," look for "alt" tags in HTML
Captions/transcriptsVideos have closed captions and text transcriptsLook for caption button in video player; verify it works with mouse and keyboard
Color contrastText meets minimum contrast ratiosNormal text: 4.5:1 minimum; large text (18pt+ or 14pt+ bold): 3:1 minimum
Keyboard navigationAll elements reachable without mouseUse Tab and Shift-Tab keys to navigate; check if you can reach all elements
Zoom functionalityContent works at 200% zoomZoom browser to 200%; verify content doesn't overlap or disappear

🌐 Universal benefits

  • Accessible content helps everyone, not just people with disabilities.
  • Example: Captions help people in noisy environments or non-native speakers; clear navigation benefits all users.
  • The excerpt notes that accessibility has "financial, social, and ethical implications" that benefit both the organization and the larger community.

🌈 Inclusion principles

🌈 What inclusion adds beyond accessibility

  • Inclusion addresses assumptions about the audience and what identities are considered "normal" or acceptable.
  • It concerns "the way that groups of people are portrayed in language and in photos."
  • For someone to feel welcome, they should "see themselves reflected positively in the content" or sense the text was written with diverse identities in mind.
  • The excerpt emphasizes this is "just as much about what you don't say or the types of identities that you don't feature" as what you do include.

💼 Why inclusion matters financially and socially

Financial impact:

  • 61% of Americans find diversity important in marketing content.
  • 38% of consumers trust brands more when they embrace diversity effectively.
  • LGBTQ+, Black, and Gen Z audiences may boycott brands that inadequately represent their identities.

Social and ethical impact:

  • Reinforces movements focused on equality and social justice.
  • "Diversity, equity, and inclusion matter because they help build a fairer society, strengthening the bonds between people and within organizations."
  • Companies have a responsibility to act against barriers that have caused unfair conditions for underrepresented groups.

🎯 Target audience vs. exclusion

Don't confuse: Defining a target audience with being exclusive.

  • A company selling women's athletic gear would naturally feature women prominently and address their concerns.
  • However, it would be a mistake to exclude (implicitly or explicitly) certain types of women who fit the target—women of color, women with disabilities, women with different body types.
  • These segments may be interested in the products but won't engage if they don't feel welcomed by the language or lack of diversity in photos.
  • Their marginalized status is reinforced by exclusionary website experiences.

🔤 DEI framework breakdown

🔤 Diversity: Representing varied identities

Diversity is about representing a wide range of identities based on age, race, gender, ability, sexuality, and so on.

  • Organizations valuing diversity engage diverse people as employees, managers, research participants, product testers.
  • They include those perspectives in external brand communication.
  • "Diversity is the first step because it extends the invitation, making people feel that they are welcome."
  • Example: People are more likely to feel welcome if they see positive representations of their identities in digital messaging.

⚖️ Equity: Actions and policies

Equity refers to the actions you take to cultivate an environment of diversity and inclusion, reflected in your policies and daily practices.

  • Ensures different groups participate and their perspectives are valued.
  • Provides resources and opportunities to groups that have traditionally been marginalized.
  • Goes beyond representation to actual policy implementation.

🤝 Inclusion: Active participation

Inclusion goes beyond inviting diverse groups to be present; it encourages them to take an active, important role in the development of ideas.

  • "Diversity is being invited to the party; inclusion is being asked to dance" (Verna Myers).
  • Involves inviting feedback from various audiences and using that feedback to improve strategies.
  • Means inviting participation from diverse groups in every aspect of the business process—product development, customer service, everything in between.

⚠️ Avoiding tokenism

  • DEI is not "checking off a box" or "tacking on" language or pictures to appease certain groups.
  • It's an entire culture where inclusivity is fostered at every level of decision-making and management.
  • Should go beyond tokenized representations during certain times of year (e.g., featuring a Black person exclusively during Black History Month).
  • Requires "year-round DEI with fair and thoughtful representation of underrepresented groups throughout your content—both internally and externally."

📝 Best practices for inclusive digital writing

🔬 Intentional market research

  • Be intentional about research that identifies different segments of your target population.
  • "Look at the available data to understand representations that can be documented such as gender, income level, geography, race, etc. Then go deeper."
  • Ask front-line team members, attend industry events, conduct focus groups to understand characteristics not easily tracked (physical ability, point of view).
  • Use research to create personas of people with different characteristics to humanize target audience members and understand their needs.

🗣️ Include diverse voices in content

  • Ideally, prioritize diversity and inclusion at all staffing levels so different identities are represented across departments and decision-making.
  • Content should be written by people from various backgrounds to better understand and engage different audience parts.
  • "At a minimum, a team should be sensitized and trained to ask tough diversity and inclusion questions and encouraged to consult with those communities where a possible problem or misunderstanding could arise."

💬 Use inclusive language

Two levels of inclusive language:

  1. General approach: Friendly and professional tone, clear and easy-to-understand writing, respectful approach that resists biased assumptions about what is "normal" or "right."

  2. Specific terminology: Be sensitive to how language is used; research and incorporate preferred terminology that people won't find offensive.

Resources mentioned:

  • Associated Press Stylebook (2019): Added section on race-related topics with language preferred by people of color from journalism organizations.
  • Conscious Style Guide: Covers sensitive topics and recommends specific terminology; mission is to "help writers and editors think critically about using language—including words, portrayals, framing, and representation—to empower instead of limit."

🖼️ Think about representation

  • Make an effort to be diverse in visual content—use photos with different types of identities represented positively.
  • Include testimonials from a variety of customers.
  • Write employee profiles to highlight diverse voices from your team.
  • While representing every identity in your target audience may not be possible, making an effort builds trust.

✅ Be authentic, not performative

  • Don't "go overboard" or come across as inauthentic.
  • Avoid using people's marginalized identities to make yourself look better.
  • Don't force a diversity message into contexts where it doesn't fit naturally.
  • "Make sure your content reflects a sincere commitment to diversity but in a way that's organic for your brand and your audience."

🧭 Implementation mindset

🧭 Courage and humility required

  • Taking steps toward social justice is always a risk.
  • Not everyone will support inclusivity efforts for different reasons; some may disengage from your brand.
  • Despite best efforts, you may say something wrong or something taken the wrong way.

🔄 Learning from mistakes

  • Humility is essential: Offer a genuine apology for misunderstandings.
  • Make an effort to better understand that person's perspective.
  • Address concerns in future content.
  • "There's always room to improve your inclusivity efforts and to better understand the people in your target audience if you are willing to listen."

🎯 Intentionality throughout the process

  • Creating truly inclusive content is "a complex process and requires a great deal of intentionality, planning, and critical thinking."
  • The excerpt emphasizes being "intentional at every step of the production process to include other voices."
  • The key is having "an open mind" and genuine commitment to understanding diverse perspectives.