🧭 Overview
🧠 One-sentence thesis
Lewis structures systematically represent bonding and non-bonding electrons in molecules and ions, with formal charge guidelines and exceptions to the octet rule determining the most plausible structures.
📌 Key points (3–5)
- What Lewis structures show: bonding between atoms (as lines) and non-bonding valence electrons (as dots), built from Lewis symbols of individual elements.
- Systematic drawing procedure: for polyatomic species, follow a step-by-step method—count total valence electrons, build skeleton, complete terminal octets first, then form multiple bonds if needed, and check formal charges.
- Formal charges guide plausibility: smaller absolute values are better; negative formal charges appear on high-EN atoms, positive on low-EN atoms; structures with same-sign charges on adjacent atoms are unlikely.
- Common confusion—Kekulé vs Lewis: Kekulé structures omit lone pairs (except when highlighting special properties), while complete Lewis structures show all electrons; remember N has 1 lone pair, O has 2, halogens have 3.
- Exceptions to the octet rule: odd-electron radicals, incomplete octets (e.g., BH₃, carbocations), and expanded valence shells (Period 3+ elements can exceed 8 electrons using d orbitals).
🔤 Fundamental concepts
🔤 Lewis symbol
The Lewis symbol is the chemical symbol of an element with valence electrons represented as dots.
- Shows only the valence electrons of a free atom.
- Example: the excerpt shows symbols for aluminum, tin, nitrogen, chlorine, and bromine with their valence electrons as dots.
🔗 Lewis structure
A Lewis structure shows the bonding between atoms as short lines (some books use pairs of dots) and non-bonding valence electrons as dots.
- Bonding pairs: pairs of valence electrons involved in a covalent bond; drawn as short lines; one line = one pair = 2 electrons.
- Lone pairs: pairs of valence electrons not involved in a covalent bond; also called non-bonding electron pairs.
- Special case: unpaired (single) electrons exist in radicals (free radicals).
🧪 Simple diatomic molecules
For simple diatomic molecules, combine the Lewis symbols of each element:
- H₂: each H needs only two electrons (a duet, not an octet).
- F₂: each F shares one pair; each F has three lone pairs.
- HCl: H and Cl share one pair; Cl has three lone pairs.
- O₂: the two O atoms share two pairs (a double bond); each O has two lone pairs.
Don't confuse: bonding pairs (shared, shown as lines) vs lone pairs (not shared, shown as dots).
📝 Drawing procedure for polyatomic species
📝 Step-by-step method
The excerpt emphasizes: "It is very important that you use the following procedure to get the correct Lewis structures for polyatomic molecules and ions."
- Count total valence electrons: for ions, adjust for charge (subtract for cations, add for anions).
- Example: NH₄⁺ has 5 (N) + 4×1 (H) − 1 (charge) = 8 valence electrons.
- Write skeletal structure:
- Hydrogen is always terminal.
- Central atoms are generally those with lowest EN; carbon is always central.
- Connect central atom to each terminal atom with a single bond.
- Subtract bonding electrons: for each single bond, subtract 2 from the total.
- Complete octets: use remaining electrons to complete terminal atoms first, then central atoms as much as possible.
- Check completion: if all atoms have octets, done.
- Form multiple bonds if needed: move lone pairs from terminal atoms to central atom to complete central octets.
- Calculate formal charges: label non-zero formal charges.
🧮 Formal charge calculation
Formal Charge on an atom = No. of valence electrons in free atoms − No. of lone pair electrons − ½ (No. of bonding electrons)
- Alternative (derived) formula: Formal Charge = No. of valence electrons in free atoms − No. of lone pair electrons − No. of covalent bonds around the atom.
- Double bonds count as 2, triple bonds as 3 in the derived formula.
- The excerpt notes Formula 1.2 (derived) is "easier to use and can be regarded as the most practical one based on experience."
🔬 CO₂ example walkthrough
- Total valence electrons: 4 (C) + 2×6 (O) = 16.
- Skeletal structure: O—C—O (carbon is always central).
- Four electrons used; 12 remain.
- Complete terminal O octets first: uses all 12 remaining electrons; central C does not have octet yet.
- Not done; proceed to next step.
- Move one lone pair from each terminal O to form double bonds: O=C=O.
- Formal charges: FC(C) = 4 − ½×(4×2) = 0; FC(O) = 6 − 4 − ½×(2×2) = 0; all zero, so structure is correct.
Key rule: "the remaining electrons should be used to give the octet of terminal atoms first!"
Key rule: "the lone-pairs can only be moved from terminal atoms to the central atom to form multiple bonds, not the other way around."
⚖️ Formal charge guidelines
⚖️ Purpose and meaning
The purpose of formal charges is to compare the difference between the number of valence electrons in the free atom and the number of electrons the atom "owns" when it is bonded.
- Smaller difference → "happier" (more stable) atom.
- The atom owns all lone pair electrons and half of the bonding electrons.
⚖️ Rules for plausibility
| Rule | Explanation |
|---|
| Sum equals total charge | The sum of all formal charges must equal the molecule or ion's total charge |
| Minimize absolute values | Formal charges should be as small as possible |
| Negative on high-EN atoms | "−" FC appears on most electronegative atoms (they "win" electrons in sharing) |
| Positive on low-EN atoms | "+" FC appears on least electronegative atoms (they "lose" electrons in sharing) |
| Avoid same-sign adjacency | Structures with same-sign formal charges on adjacent atoms are unlikely |
⚖️ Example—why one CO₂ structure is better
The excerpt asks: "Why is the following structure not the best way to show the Lewis structure of CO₂?"
- The better structure (O=C=O) has all formal charges equal to zero.
- A structure with non-zero formal charges would be less plausible even if it satisfies the octet rule.
🚫 Special case—fluorine
Key rule: "F is the atom with the highest electronegativity; therefore, F atom NEVER has the '+' formal charge in any plausible Lewis structure!"
🎨 Kekulé structures
🎨 What they omit
Organic species are usually shown as Kekulé structures with all the lone pair electrons completely omitted (with exception to the lone pairs shown to highlight special properties).
- Complete Lewis structures show all bonding and lone pair electrons.
- Kekulé structures show only bonds (lines); lone pairs are understood but not drawn.
- Examples given: ethanol, acetic acid, ethyl amine, ethyl bromide.
🎨 Counting invisible lone pairs
"To count how many lone pairs should be involved on a certain atom, apply the octet rule."
| Atom | Typical lone pairs |
|---|
| N | 1 lone pair |
| O | 2 lone pairs |
| Halogens | 3 lone pairs |
- All atoms (except H) should have 8 electrons around them.
- Don't confuse: just because lone pairs aren't drawn in Kekulé structures doesn't mean they aren't there.
🔓 Exceptions to the octet rule
🔓 Odd number of electrons
If total valence electrons is odd, the octet rule cannot be applied to all atoms.
The neutral species that contain an unpaired electron are called radicals (or free radicals).
- NO molecule: two possible structures; formal charge guideline selects the one with zero formal charges as better.
- NO₂ molecule: contains an unpaired electron.
- Alkyl radicals: e.g., •CH₃ with 7 total valence electrons; the carbon has an unpaired electron.
Example: •CH₃ structure shows three C–H bonds and one unpaired electron on carbon.
🔓 Incomplete octet
An incomplete octet means the atom has less than 8 electrons involved.
This occurs when:
- Total valence electrons < 8, or
- Formal charge concerns favor incomplete octet.
BH₃ molecule: total valence electrons = 6; central boron does not get an octet.
BF₃ molecule: even though all atoms could get octets, the actual structure keeps boron with an incomplete octet because formal charge guidelines favor it. Similar examples: BeF₂, AlCl₃.
CH₃⁺ (carbocation): a reactive intermediate in organic reactions; formal charge calculations show the "+" charge lies on C; carbon has an incomplete octet.
🔓 Expanded valence shell
For elements in Period 3 or higher, they can have more than 8 electrons if it helps to lower the formal charges.
- Common examples: central atoms P, S, Cl, etc.
- Sometimes multiple double bonds are necessary to minimize formal charge.
- Example: phosphate anion (PO₄³⁻) structure shows expanded valence on P.
Why this works: "Elements in Period 3 (or higher) have 3 (or more than 3) principal shells, so the d orbital is available in the valence shell. That is why they can accommodate more than 8 electrons."
🔓 Key limitation
Key Takeaway: "For elements in 2nd period, C, N, O, F and Ne, the maximum number of electrons involved in Lewis structure is eight!!!"
- Second-period elements cannot expand their valence shell.
- Don't confuse: Period 3+ elements can exceed 8 electrons; Period 2 elements cannot.
🔄 Resonance structures (preview)
🔄 What resonance means
In cases in which more than one reasonable (plausible) Lewis structure can be drawn for a species, these structures are called resonance structures or resonance contributors.
- Resonance structures can be equivalent or non-equivalent.
- The actual structure is a hybrid of all resonance contributors.
🔄 Equivalent resonance—carbonate anion
CO₃²⁻ example: following Step 6, the double bond can be built between central C and any of the three terminal O atoms, generating three structures.
- They are not identical; they are equivalent.
- Connected by double-headed resonance arrows.
- All three are at the same energy level and have the same stability, so they make equal contributions to the actual structure.
- Experimental evidence: all carbon-oxygen bonds in CO₃²⁻ are the same length, longer than a regular double bond.
Don't confuse: the resonance arrow (double-headed) is different from reaction arrows; "Resonance structures have to be connected using resonance arrows."